Committee Of Adjustment in Ontario

What is the Committee of Adjustment?

The Committee of Adjustment is a quasi-judicial board established under the Planning Act with four primary responsibilities:

1. Grant minor variances from zoning requirements
2. Approve lot severances and consents
3. Hear appeals of certain municipal decisions
4. Review other planning matters as assigned by municipality

"Quasi-judicial" means Committee operates like a court - following formal procedures, hearing evidence, and making decisions based on legal criteria - but isn't a true court. Committee decisions can be appealed to Ontario Land Tribunal but not through typical court system.

‍

Committee Composition and Structure

Membership:

Committee members (typically 5-7) are appointed by municipal council. Appointments are ideally balanced to include:

• Planning professionals or building officials
• Lawyers or people with legal background
• Members with real estate or development experience
• Community representatives
• Members with no particular expertise (general citizens)

Most municipalities aim for diverse Committee reflecting community perspective.

Term:

Members typically serve 2-4 year terms, renewable. This provides continuity while allowing periodic renewal.

Qualifications:

No formal educational requirements exist, though planning knowledge is valuable. Most municipalities look for diverse backgrounds and local knowledge.

Chair and Vice-Chair:

Committee selects chair and vice-chair from membership. Chair manages meetings and ensures procedures are followed.

‍

Committee Authority and Jurisdiction

Committee has specific, limited authority established by Planning Act:

Authority to Grant Minor Variances:

Committee can grant relief from zoning standards when four statutory tests are satisfied. These are the only variances Committee can grant - not use changes, not density increases beyond "minor," not broad modifications. Only dimensional and performance standards are variance subject matter.

Authority to Approve Consents:

Committee approves lot severances (creating 1-3 new parcels from existing property). Committee authority is limited - they can't approve subdivisions (4+ lots) or create rights-of-way on their own initiative, though they work with municipalities on these.

Authority to Hear Appeals:

Committee hears appeals of certain municipal staff decisions - building permit refusals, site plan appeal situations, official plan amendment deferrals.

Authority NOT Held:

Committee cannot:

• Approve subdivisions (only severances up to 3 lots)
• Change zoning (only grant relief from existing zoning)
• Amend Official Plan
• Override Council decisions
• Consider matters outside Planning Act authority

Understanding Committee's limited authority prevents requesting approval they can't grant.

‍

The Four Statutory Tests for Variance

Committee can approve variance ONLY when applicant demonstrates all four tests are satisfied:

Test 1: Minor in Nature

Variance cannot be substantial. Modifications must be modest - typically 10-30% deviation from bylaw standards. Beyond that, variance becomes amendment material.

Test 2: Desirable Development

Proposed use must be appropriate for area. Residential development in residential neighborhood is desirable. Industrial facility in quiet residential area is not. This test examines neighborhood fit and compatibility.

Test 3: Maintains General Intent of Zoning Bylaw

Even with variance, project must respect spirit of zoning. Zoning requiring 25% green space maintains intent with 20% green space variance. Eliminating green space entirely fails this test.

Test 4: Maintains General Intent of Official Plan

Project must align with long-term community planning vision. Official Plan supporting residential intensification makes variance enabling more residential units consistent. Official Plan protecting agricultural lands makes agricultural conversion variance inconsistent.

All four tests must be satisfied. Committee cannot approve variance failing even one test.

‍

Committee Hearing Process

Before the Hearing:

1. Application Submission. Completed application with site plan, planning justification statement, supporting documentation.
2. Circulation. Municipality circulates application to agencies and notifies public. Circulation typically 10-14 days.
3. Comments. Agencies submit comments. Public can submit written comments for Committee consideration.

At the Hearing:

1. Hearing Opens. Chair calls meeting to order. Explains procedures and what will happen.
2. Applicant Presentation. You present application, explaining variance need and addressing four tests. Keep presentation focused and professional - 15-20 minutes typical.
3. Questions. Committee members ask clarifying questions about your proposal, four tests, and project details.
4. Agency Comments. Relevant agencies (if present) present their positions and concerns.
5. Public Comment. Neighbors and interested public can speak for or against application. This is sometimes emotional - remain professional regardless of community opposition.
6. Deliberation. Committee discusses application and votes.

After the Hearing:

Decision is typically announced same day, with formal written decision following within days.

‍

Committee Decisions

Committee can:

Approve Variance. Grant complete relief requested. This is what you want.

Approve with Conditions. Grant variance but require specified modifications or actions. Must meet conditions before implementing variance.

Defer. Ask for additional information or studies. Application returns for resubmission addressing deficiencies.

Refuse Variance. Deny application. Applicant can appeal to Ontario Land Tribunal within 30 days.

‍

Consent Applications (Lot Severances)

Committee approves severances (creating 1-3 lots from existing property) under different criteria than variances.

Consent criteria include:

• Proposed lots meet or will meet zoning requirements
• Appropriate road access exists
• Municipal services (water, sewer) available or plan for provision exists
• No negative impacts on surrounding properties
• Proposal aligns with Official Plan

Unlike variance (meeting four tests), consent approval is more discretionary - Committee assesses overall appropriateness.

Consent Process:

Same as variance - application, circulation, hearing, decision.

Timeline: Typically 8-12 weeks for straightforward consent.

‍

Successfully Presenting Before Committee

Before Hearing:

• Prepare thoroughly. Understand your four-test arguments completely. Anticipate Committee questions.
• Know the property. Site conditions, surrounding context, neighborhood patterns.
• Research precedents. Similar variances Committee has approved. Use these to argue why yours should succeed.
• Professional presentation materials. Clear site plans, renderings if applicable, written justification statement.
• Understand Committee makeup. Know Committee members' backgrounds if possible. Tailor presentation accordingly.

During Hearing:

• Be professional. Dress appropriately. Speak clearly. Maintain composed demeanor regardless of opposition.
• Stay on topic. Answer questions asked. Don't volunteer information about unrelated issues.
• Address the tests. Structure presentation around four tests. Explain how your proposal satisfies each one.
• Use visuals. Site plans, photos, renderings communicate more clearly than words alone.
• Acknowledge concerns. If legitimate concerns are raised, address them. Don't dismiss community input.
• Be concise. Committee appreciates focused presentations. Rambling presentations lose attention.

Key Don'ts:

• Don't argue emotion ("I really want to build this").
• Don't criticize Committee or municipal staff.
• Don't make threats ("I'll sue if you deny this").
• Don't present unverified claims as fact.
• Don't expect Committee sympathy-they follow legal criteria.

‍

Committee of Adjustment Across Southern Ontario

Kawartha Lakes:

• Committee meets regularly (often monthly)
• Typical application review 6-10 weeks
• Appeals to Ontario Land Tribunal available
• Contact: City of Kawartha Lakes Planning Department

Peterborough:

• Similar process and timeline
• Regular meeting schedule
• Professional staff support
• Contact: City of Peterborough Planning Services

Durham Region Municipalities (Oshawa, Ajax, Whitby):

• Each municipality has own Committee
• Process and timeline similar across Durham
• Slight variations in procedures between municipalities
• Contact individual municipality planning departments

Each municipality has specific procedures-check your municipality's website for meeting schedule, application form, and detailed requirements.

‍

Common Misconceptions About Committee

Misconception 1: "Community opposition will block approval."

Reality: Opposition is noted but doesn't determine outcome. Committee decides based on four tests, not votes on support. Strong opposition alone doesn't block variance meeting four tests.

Misconception 2: "Political connections matter."

Reality: Committee is quasi-judicial body required to follow legal criteria. Political considerations are improper. Professional presentation of legal arguments determines outcome.

Misconception 3: "Committee always grants variances."

Reality: Committee grants variances meeting all four tests. Variances failing tests are denied. Success depends on actual test satisfaction, not Committee leniency.

Misconception 4: "Committee can change zoning."

Reality: Committee has no authority to amend zoning. Only variance relief within existing zoning is possible. Zoning changes require municipal council, not Committee.

Misconception 5: "Approval is automatic if application is complete."

Reality: Completeness is necessary but not sufficient. Committee must assess four tests. Complete applications failing tests are denied.

‍

Appealing Committee Decisions

Appeal Deadline: 30 days from Committee decision.

Appeal Authority: Ontario Land Tribunal (formerly Local Planning Appeal Tribunal).

Appeal Process: File notice of appeal with tribunal. Tribunal schedules hearing. Applicant and municipality present positions. Adjudicator issues decision.

Appeal Considerations:

• Appeals are expensive ($5,000-$15,000+ in legal/consultant costs)
• Appeals take time (4-12 months typically)
• Adjudicator reviews whether Committee properly applied law
• New evidence can be introduced on appeal
• Adjudicator can uphold, overturn, or modify Committee decision

Appeal makes sense if Committee made legal error or misapplied tests. Appeal doesn't make sense if Committee correctly determined tests not satisfied.

‍

Conclusion

Committee of Adjustment is the municipal body responsible for granting zoning variances and consent approvals in Ontario. Understanding Committee authority, hearing procedures, and four statutory tests significantly improves application success.

Our team at TD Consulting has presented hundreds of applications before Committees across Southern Ontario. We assess whether situations qualify under four tests, prepare compelling presentations, and represent clients through Committee hearings professionally.

Need help with Committee of Adjustment hearing? Contact us for representation and guidance.

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

How long before I can implement a variance?

Immediately upon Committee approval. Don't wait for formal written decision-verbal approval is sufficient. However, obtain written decision for documentation.

Can I request variance and appeal simultaneously?

No. Appeal must be within 30 days of decision. If granted, there's nothing to appeal. If refused, you appeal the refusal.

How many times can I reapply for same variance?

Technically unlimited, but reapplying immediately after denial is futile. Redesign addressing test failures, wait reasonable period, then reapply.

What's the difference between Committee and Council?

Committee of Adjustment handles variances and severances. Municipal Council handles zoning amendments, Official Plan amendments, and broad policy decisions. Different authorities, different processes.

Do I need a lawyer for Committee hearing?

Not required, but professional representation (lawyer, planning consultant, or both) significantly improves approval odds.

Can Committee conditions be modified after approval?

Typically no. Conditions are binding. Modification requires requesting variance to the variance (unlikely to succeed) or negotiating with municipality.